The (Outpost) Polls Are Open
Learn more
Nov 17, 2026 • 5 min read

How The 51st tripled their newsletter signup rate during election coverage with an Outpost registration wall

Case Study: The 51st

You’d never expect a single pop-up to change your business, but there’s power in a well timed ask. “This is NOT a paywall,” the modal says when you’ve read three articles in a month on The 51st. It is not a paywall. It’s a registration wall and it means that you have to become a newsletter subscriber before you can read another story. 

This small request—give us your email to read more—has led to huge results for The 51st. It tripled their newsletter signups during this past election season when they saw record rates of visitors seeking out their voter guides. Maddie Poore, co-founder of The 51st and its Director of Growth and Engagement, told me they usually see about 1k new subscribers every month. During May and June, they grew their list by 6k new readers.

Increased traffic due to the demand for election information played a key role in this boost, but Maddie credits the Outpost registration wall with their newsletter growth. Otherwise, all those visitors discovering The 51st for the first time might have just bounced away forever.

A registration wall beats a dismissable newsletter ask

The 51st had a splashy launch in 2024, raising over $276k to fund their worker-led, local news venture. They’re still primarily member-backed two years later. But at the end of last year, they decided, instead of doing the traditional year end member drive, they would do a newsletter subscriber drive in an effort to vastly expand their audience.

Hidden Features of Outpost (Thurs Nov 19 noon PT)
November 26, 2026
12:00 pm - 1:00 pm PST (3:00 pm - 4:00 pm EST)
Virtual event
One-Click Registration

It was then that they enabled the registration wall in Outpost. On normal traffic days, they see a few signups, but anytime there is a flood of attention to their site—like when The Washington Post cut a third of its staff in February and their fans promoted The 51st—they’d see the newsletter list grow too. They gained 3k newsletter subscribers during the unexpected February boost with help from the reg wall. By the time their election traffic spiked in May and June, the system was already in place ready to turn fresh visitors into newsletter subscribers. 

The 51st’s registration wall reads “This is NOT a paywall” and asks for your email to continue reading
The 51st’s registration wall reads “This is NOT a paywall” and asks for your email to continue reading

Maddie said one reason the registration wall was so effective during election season was that new readers checking out their voter guide would want to view multiple other stories in the same visit, going from the main guide to sub-stories on specific races. They’d hit the three article limit quickly and then, give their email address to keep reading.

The growth from the reg wall outweighs the downsides

Gaining newsletter subscribers is clearly great for publishers, but what do readers think of the reg wall experience? There’s two ways you’d know if there was an issue for readers. One is that you’d get higher than usual unsubscribes, showing that people didn’t really want to be on your list. The other is that you get complaints.

The 51st has not yet seen noticeable changes in unsubscribes yet from readers who join via the registration wall. They do sometimes hear from readers who are confused about why they’re getting a newsletter prompt when they’re already on the list. All those readers have to do is sign in and the reg wall won’t show to them anymore. Maddie said it’s only been a few notes and the benefits of newsletter growth far outweigh a few customer service emails.

There are also people who decide to leave instead of give their email when presented with the wall. It doesn’t affect their experience much because they can just go incognito or switch devices and access stories again. It’s easy enough to bypass the registration wall, which is somewhat by design. No one is trying to force readers into joining newsletter lists. It’s a gentle, but disruptive reminder you that you’re getting a lot of use out of the site and that you might also find value in the newsletter.

How this rapid newsletter growth changes the paid member strategy

Because the registration wall has been so successful in growing their newsletter list, it’s changing The 51st’s paid member acquisition strategy. They launched with a core base of fans who knew their backstory and passionately invested in their newsroom. An astonishing 27% of their registered readers were paying members before election season began. Now, that they’re two years into their venture, they’re widening their reach to attract new readers who’ve never heard of them. 

Paid member growth hasn’t been proportional to the newsletter growth because this audience is colder, but The 51st did see a bump in paid members during election season, adding 161 new ones. Unlike the founding members, these new visitors may not know anything about The 51st. They discovered a story online or heard about the site from a friend. The 51st was one of the only outlets offering deep local election coverage so it quickly became the go-to source for D.C. residents, most of whom were newly becoming aware of what this newsroom offers the city. These visitors might be intrigued, but they’re less immediately ready to pay than the base that’s been with The 51st since the beginning.

As your newsletter gets bigger, a smaller percentage of those new readers will go paid but having them on your list offers you more opportunities to convince them, either right when they join or with a targeted promotion later. Maddie says she plans to experiment with their welcome automation in Outpost to persuade more of these fresh fans to become paying members sooner. 

The 51st’s welcome flow makes an immediate ask for readers to become paid members
The 51st’s welcome flow makes an immediate ask for readers to become paid members

Grow your own newsletter faster with a registration wall 

A registration wall gives you the opportunity to retain more of your site traffic than an easily ignorable newsletter block. If you want your newsletter growing faster, it’s worth trying within Outpost. 

You can fully customize the design and you control how many stories visitors can read before they see the pop-up. What works best will vary based on how frequently you publish, but Outpost recommends starting with 2 or 3 articles per month and adjusting up or down based on the number of signups you see. Some publishers even set theirs to 0 to enforce the reg wall for all new visitors. You can track how much your newsletter is growing by checking your Outpost weekly reports. Those will show how many people joined your list through each CTA on your site, including the reg wall. 

The 51st’s reg wall results are compelling. They’re a reminder that no matter how good the work you’re doing is, how fascinating the stories you publish are, or how much your community recommends your publication, first time visitors will be one time visitors unless they are directed to take the next step. That next step is joining your newsletter. The registration wall is a well-timed invitation that opens the door to a longer relationship with your newest readers.


Start your free trial with Outpost to try our Metered Registration Wall. Plus, join us at upcoming events to learn how you can grow your member-backed publication this year.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to Outpost.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.