The flip side of paid subscriber growth is mounting customer support requests. You’re running a publication that should be mostly self-service, but subscribers have questions. They can’t log in. They need a refund. They want to update their credit card. The systems you choose determine how much of this communication you have to do as your subscription grows.
When Hyperallergic decided to make the move from Newspack to Ghost and Outpost last year, it was because managing their membership in WordPress was getting unwieldy. “I was doing a lot of customer service. Two to three hours of customer service every day,” publisher and co-founder Veken Gueyikian said. WordPress wasn’t designed for memberships, he pointed out, and they wanted a system that could automate more of the communication with their subscribers.
Hyperallergic is an independent arts and culture publication founded in 2009 by Veken Gueyikian and Hrag Vartanian, before many options existed to properly support their work. They started on WordPress, later switched to Newspack (which is built on top of WordPress) and now, have been running with Ghost and Outpost for about a year. This latest move has cut their customer support down to almost to zero—going from a dozen daily requests to maybe one a day. That’s opened up a lot more time in Veken’s schedule to focus on the growth of their publication. Better yet, their new tech stack is saving them $50-60k a year over the previous one.
What cuts down on the subscriber emails
Log in and sign up were top problems on their old system, with a lot of the authentication codes going to spam. With 130k readers and 8k paying members, Hyperallergic was fielding tons of these help requests daily. Ghost fixed this problem immediately with better deliverability of those emails.
Outpost’s autoresponder solved the bulk of the rest of the customer complaints. Paid members get reminders that they will be charged at 30 days and 7 days out from their annual renewals. Sending these reminders is becoming the law now in many places, including in New York City, where Hyperallergic is based. Beyond compliance, renewal reminders reduce angry readers, potential chargebacks and refund requests, which are expensive because publishers often eat the payment processing fees.

Cancellations are more functional too. In their previous system, members would go to cancel and it wouldn’t take effect. Now, when members cancel, it actually ends the subscription, and Outpost’s autoresponder picks up from there, sending emails that work to win back that subscriber. Veken says they’re using all of the retention and cancellation emails recommended in Outpost because it’s an important opportunity to retain valuable members.
How the move to Ghost and Outpost went
When you’re as established as Hyperallergic is, you have a lot of moving parts to consider when making a platform switch. Their previous stack wasn’t just Newspack and WordPress. It also included ActiveCampaign for newsletters, BlueLena for automations and Parse.ly for analytics. Veken didn’t share any complaints about these tools, but managing them together made for a complex business backend.
“All day I was dealing with the platform. Fixing plug-ins. Updating plug-ins. Fixing a bug. Reporting a bug. A lot of my day was wrestling with tech,” Veken said. That pain prompted the search for a better option and Ghost emerged as an obvious choice due to its design for member-backed publications.
The Ghost team assisted with Hyperallergic’s migration, including porting 30k+ articles, all newsletter readers and paying members over to the new site. This is a free service Ghost offers to publishers making the transition. Veken says this could have been smoother. Around 5% of the stories needed fixing because an author or byline was missing. They also had to double check their paid membership renewal times. If your paid membership is as large and long-running as Hyperallergic’s is, sometimes you have people on multiple archived payment tiers. Many platform migrations have no issues, but it’s good to spot check Stripe during any migration to ensure members are on their correct plans and renewal timelines.
In addition to memberships, Hyperallergic runs curated advertising on their site. Veken founded an ads network for art publishers years ago and, to this day, sells ads to art institutions, museums, nonprofits, and schools who want to reach their audience. They needed a solution for dynamically injecting these ads and Outpost’s Ad Campaigns tool was an easy switch from what Newspack offered. With Outpost’s Ad Campaigns, you can schedule campaigns, choose audiences to display them to, and decide where the ads show up. Once the campaign is done, that ad will stop showing on the site.

Hyperallergic joined Outpost right away alongside Ghost because they already had automations running in BlueLena that they knew were essential to their membership business. Veken said, “Outpost had great automations from the get-go, but just the right ones for us. We didn't need anything more. It is a thoughtful, well done system.”
Where they see their biggest growth potential
Now that Hyperallergic has settled into the Ghost and Outpost universe, they’re working on a brand new site design and a relaunch of their membership. They’re planning to introduce a paywall for the first time. Up until now, members have been more like recurring donors, contributing to keep the site going but offered the same level of access as free accounts.
The Hyperallergic team has a lot more flexibility with who sees what content in their new system. Veken’s already been testing a metered registration wall, which has worked well for growing their newsletter. With the membership relaunch, the plan is to introduce a metered paywall that pops up after you’ve read a few stories. They’re also going to try Ghost’s fixed paywall on some stories. Both the registration wall and the metered paywall are options inside Outpost’s CTA settings. You can choose how many posts people can read before these show and when they get displayed (on certain scroll depth or on page load.)
With the paywall in place, Hyperallergic will begin offering group and institutional subscriptions to their many organizational partners. Outpost lets you sell group subscriptions on your site or invoice institutions behind the scenes. Automatic communications with the group subscription buyers and subscription recipients are already built-in to Outpost’s autoresponder so all Veken will have to do is set the pricing and tell people about it.

Optimizing email marketing is also on Veken’s radar. That includes a robust relaunch campaign with emails aimed at enticing more of Hyperallergic’s 130k+ readers to become paid members. It also might include testing new iterations of their free welcome flow and paid onboarding with Outpost’s autoresponder to see if they can improve conversion and retention there too.
Choose systems that grow with you
When you launch a publication, you’re thinking about how to get traffic to your site, how to get the word out and how to grow your paid membership. As soon as you have traction, you need systems that can keep up with your reader and payments growth. Hyperallergic’s new home on Outpost and Ghost not only saves them tens of thousands of dollars a year, but it also gave them back hundreds of hours to focus reaching their goals. They no longer have to field customer support requests all day or fix buggy plug-ins. And their paid members aren’t having bad experiences where they can’t log in or adjust their plan on their own.
Migrating platforms sounds daunting but as Hyperallergic shows us, the upside can be huge.
Ghost offers a strong CMS and membership platform. Outpost brings an automation and monetization suite that ensures revenue keeps growing, while eliminating basic customer support asks around onboarding, renewals, cancellations and more. It’s a system that serves the publisher and the readers equally well. If you’re spending a lot of time or money managing your current tech stack, it might be time to make the move to Ghost and Outpost.
Start your free trial with Outpost to try the Best Damn Autoresponder for Ghost, Metered Paywalls and Ad Campaigns and join us at upcoming events to learn how you can grow your member-backed publication this year.